How to prevent abuse of bank guarantee?

The unconditional, “first demand” bank guarantees are considered to be among the most secure forms of protection against various risks in business. By issuing the bank guarantee, the bank as a guarantor undertakes to make a payment to the recipient of guarantee (the beneficiary) in the event of non-performance of contractual obligations by a third party. When a demand is made to the guarantor and is in compliance with the terms of the guarantee, the guarantor (the bank) is under obligation to pay to the beneficiary regardless of the underlying relationship between the beneficiary and the grantor. However, due to their abstract nature and independence from the basic legal transaction, various abuses of bank guarantees may occur.

The courts will rarely interfere in the realization of the bank guarantee, and there are only a few circumstances where a grantor of bank guarantee can prevent the beneficiary from obtaining payment. According to Slovenian case law, the courts may intervene in case of abuse of bank guarantee where the beneficiary of the bank guarantee has acted fraudulently or in contrary with the principle of conscientiousness and fairness, namely by issuing an interim order preventing the guarantor (the bank) from honoring the guarantee. For example, the abuse of bank guarantee can be inferred from calling for payment under unconditional bank guarantee despite previous unambiguous statements by the beneficiary confirming complete performance of works or after early termination of underlying agreement and, furthermore, in case of obvious and clear breaches of underlying contract by the beneficiary.

In event of abuse of bank guarantee by the beneficiary, the grantor will need to act quickly and file a motion for an interim order (injunction) in order to prevent a bank from honoring the bank guarantee.

RELATED POSTS
JUDGMENT OF THE COURT OF JUSTICE REGARDING THE ACT ON JUDICIAL PROTECTION OF FORMER HOLDERS OF ELIGIBLE LIABILITIES

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT OF JUSTICE REGARDING THE ACT ON JUDICIAL PROTECTION OF FORMER HOLDERS OF ELIGIBLE LIABILITIES

With the adoption of the Act on Judicial Protection Procedure for Former Holders of Eligible Liabilities of Banks (Act on…

Read more
IMPLEMENTATION OF THE EU DIRECTIVE ON WORK-LIFE BALANCE

IMPLEMENTATION OF THE EU DIRECTIVE ON WORK-LIFE BALANCE

The Directive (EU) 2019/1158 on work-life balance for parents and carers came into effect in August of this year. It…

Read more
Withdrawal from case-law on the publicity effect of entries in the land register in light of the starting point of the subjective limitation period for a damages claim

Withdrawal from case-law on the publicity effect of entries in the land register in light of the starting point of the subjective limitation period for a damages claim

In Case No III Ips 38/2021, the Supreme Court of the Republic of Slovenia has mitigated its jurisprudence on the…

Read more

Address:

Dalmatinova ulica 2
SI-1000 Ljubljana, Slovenia

Phone:

+386 59 097 400
+386 59 097 410

Email:

info@s-k.law

Social: